A few days ago, New York Magazine published an article attacking Patrick Lawrence‘s coverage of new information from an anonymous analyst known as the Forensicator. Patrick Lawrence is a foreign correspondent at The Nation, the oldest continuously published weekly magazine in America. His article mentioned Disobedient Media‘s report on analysis published by the Forensicator which suggests that files published by Guccifer 2.0 had been copied locally, not hacked, which has serious implications for the Russian Hacking narrative and for the DNC.

The New York Magazine‘s coverage of the issue was disconcertingly inaccurate. They characterize the Forensicator as having claimed that DNC information must have been leaked by an insider. The New York Mag wrote: “Yesterday, The Nation published an article by journalist Patrick Lawrence purporting to demonstrate that last summer’s pivotal DNC hack was, in fact, an inside job.”

However, the Forensicator’s work only purports that the Guccifer 2.0 files were copied locally, and that the information was not hacked. The Forensicator‘s work never attempts to positively identify the perpetrators of the DNC leak or the identity of Guccifer 2.0. The Forensicator‘s analysis simply shows in a methodical and precise manner who it could not have been; namely, Russian hackers supposedly behind the Guccifer 2.0 persona.

The author of the sardonic article, Brian Feldman, also took to Twitter to express his views on the subject:

In their coverage of this topic, The New York Mag ignores the voices of a well respected group of former intelligence officers known as VIPS, or Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity, who published a memorandum sent to President Trump that cited the Forensicator’s work. That the Foreniscator‘s findings were the starting point for a memorandum sent by experienced intelligence veterans such as Bill Binney, Ray McGovern and Skip Folden as well as many others, speaks to the significance of the Forensicator‘s work.

The New York Magazine dismissed these highly credentialed individuals, instead focusing on some of the individuals who had tweeted The Nation’s article, in order to somehow discredit the contents of the article by association. Such a dishonest framing device does not address the contents of the analysis in any way, and represents a small fraction of those who have reported on this important analysis. This intellectual dishonesty continues when Lawrence’s work is called “the extremely long-winded product of a crank.”

The sarcasm which drips from the entire piece by the New York Magazine seems to be intended as an attack on the reputation of the author, Patrick Lawrence, and the publication, The Nation.  Mr. Feldman spends little to no time making coherent criticisms of the article’s content and its cited sources.

Fascinatingly, the New York Magazine article not only fails to substantively counter the Forensicator or VIPS’s conclusions, it also does not provide any substantive evidence that the DNC was hacked. The piece also neglects to mention that authorities have never analyzed the DNC servers, instead relying on the word of the private company Crowdstrike.

Disobedient Media previously reported  the analysis of Adam Carter, which suggested that the Guccifer 2.0 persona may have been perpetrated by Crowdstrike in concert with the DNC to pre-emptively smear any DNC information published by Wikileaks. Crowdstrike has notable connections to the Atlantic Council, a think tank sponsored in part by controversial financier George Soros.

Adam Carter also published a response to the New York Mag article earlier today, which delves into the line-by-line misrepresentations in the piece. Carter writes: “Feldman misrepresents the goals of the article, VIPS’ interest and the goal of the researchers/analysts that all of this relates to.”

Ray McGovern, a cofounder of VIPS, has appeared on RT to speak about the implications of the Forensicator’s analysis, in addition to appearances with LarouchePAC and others.


Consortium News reported the memorandum published by VIPS, which corroborated some important aspects of the Forensicator’s analysis, and cited their work. Signatories on the document included William Binney, former NSA Technical Director for World Geopolitical and Military Analysis, Skip Folden, independent analyst, retired IBM Program Manager for Information Technology US, Ray McGovern, former U.S. Army Infantry/Intelligence officer and CIA analyst, and others, which are shown in full below, via the report by Consortium News.

9 Thoughts on “New York Magazine Attacks The Nation For Questioning Russian Hacking Narrative”

  • The truth will out. Forensicator, Adam Carter & the VIPS report is accurate and unassailable. If you know anything about IT at all, you will be convinced 100%.

  • Truth has a crazy way of working itself out into the open. Democrats and the media are going to twist themselves in knots trying to keep things under wraps…

    Even if it appears they are getting way with it they aren’t. Justice will be done – even if we can’t see it.

  • I remember reading about this a couple of weeks ago but I can’t remember where. This is fascinating and it will be very interesting to see the pushback by the various accusers and media who pushed this narrative.

  • Interesting…… because I watched an interview with a Former NSA Official on 08-14-17 that agreed with the Forensicator’s story of the data file being Downloaded LOCALLY….

  • so where is the technical analysis of New York Magazine? I saw that report from Vips and I think they even challenged anyone to refute it. Is this Magazine going to just bark or do they also have teeth? I say bring it!!

  • Its about time a journalist reports on the truth. It makes me sad when I see only propaganda being pushed out from most MSM anymore. It seems they really want a war with Russia rather than admit HRC lost, get over it dems if you start thinking about the people whom you represent and their needs maybe our world will get a lot nicer.

Leave a Reply